It wasn’t a terrible start to the year! Here’s January’s list complete with a picture of where most of my reading takes place
I love Singh’s book crack but I’m impatient with the Trinity section of the story. The problem I’m having is that all the men and women are beginning to be the same and have the same problems/strengths/weaknesses. I need one of the woman in her stories to not have a trauma based in the loss of her close family at a young age or an unfeeling mother and to be carrying that trauma around in a bloody backpack. I don’t doubt that losing a parent at a young age is traumatic and gives children a certain outlook. When I was born, my mother was 24, 10 years earlier her mother died, I lived with someone whose mother died when he was 6, I have two godchildren who’s father died when they were coming up to 4. Was/is there emotions and reactions that they carry that I don’t, yes but it’s much more subtle than Singh’s characters have. Memories, even traumatic ones, are generally not remembered in the vivid detail that her heroines remember them, and it come up as much as you’d think. This is their normal, the trauma you carry isn’t as easy to define or recognise as Singh seems to think. The stuff that was interesting was about the ‘pack’, how did a divergent, bunch of water changelings make a pack and how you lead and live within that (and you can fuck off with the dominance, they’re not wolves or cats, where that makes some sense), it should have been far more interesting than it was although there were some great tentacle jokes though. I want to know more about what is happening in the overall story and the next book is another spirited away heroine, which is just repeating the Sahara/Kaleb story from Heart of Obsidian although it seems we have a damaged hero who needs love to solve all their problems. Actually that’s my issue. Love doesn’t solve deep seated emotional trauma and anxiety, at best you learn to cope and deal (sure after a while that dealing looks like a cure but it’s not entirely) but in the interest of a HEA, Singh shortcuts that and given that she gives them such a terrible backstory, I struggle with how easily they overcome it. She’s a better author than that. So it was good for keeping up with the overarching story, but not enough depth for the main characters or that overarching story. There was also a ‘twist’ that I saw coming as soon as I met the character. Could do better but still a very enjoyable way to spend a day.
A Treacherous Curse – Deanna RaybournIt took me ages to read the first one of these books and then I read the others in a matter of days and I’m going to write about both of them, rather than each one. They are so much fun. On the one hand they feel out of time but on the other they really suit. I really enjoyed them and I love Veronica and her attitude but I also am enjoying how she’s learning to understand how to be a friend. I think it’s deliberate that she and Stoker are both on the outside looking in and I’m glad we finally got to meet Stoker’s ex wife in ‘A Treacherous Curse’ and put that piece of the puzzle together. I suspect though that we’ll see in the next book that Stoker could have family, if he’d let his brothers in, whereas Veronica won’t because they are all horrible and that was brilliantly observed.
This has been sitting in my Kindle TBR list since 2014 and it should have been fascinating but it was badly written. It’s not that it wasn’t interesting but it didn’t have a proper narrative, the typesetting was all over the place and it was clearly written to cash in on Americans interest while Downton Abbey was running. It’s such a good story, why they came to England, that Edward VII was receptive because he was bored and his mother wouldn’t let him do any work (and he was a bit thick in mind and later, in stature!) but it’s badly told we know that many of these marriages didn’t work but we never follow them from beginning to end and get a sense of why these women and/or their families wanted to do this. I would also say that in completely ignoring the Caton sisters. It could have been so much better and I’m sure that there are better books on the subject.
The Girl in the Mask – Marie-Louise JensenThis was so much fun, it’s set in Bath at the time of the George I and the Jacobite Rebellion of 1715. I don’t know much about this period of English history, I tend to stop at the Civil War, know a bit the reign of Charles II and then pick up again around George III. So the later Stuarts and the early Hanovers are a bit of a mystery. So I didn’t know a lot about this although I do at least know who the Old and Young Prentenders are! This is so good on how few options girls had at this time. I love that the nicest men in this story are also completely obstructive, not because they are bad people but because they lack the imagination to see a young woman who has energy and is clever and can’t possible imagine that they could look after themselves or aren’t interested in dresses and balls and might be in fear of being married off or sent into white slavery! It was a fun book and I’m going to recommend it to every young girl that I know.
Tess of the Road – Rachel Hartman This was my birthday present to my back in August. Could we also just take a minute to admire the cover. I managed to leave it at Christina and Fred’s and didn’t get it back until October and then didn’t pick it up until this month. It was delightful but not light. The book is about finding out how to be a decent human being, to live a worthwhile life when you feel worthless and are full of grief and shame. Yes, I did say it was delightful, it has lots of other things going on, but it right at the end when Tess apologised for something she had done and meant it but didn’t hate herself. That was lovely. This is apparently a two part story and I know from other books that Hartman has written that she takes her time, I hope she doesn’t take a lot longer because I want to read more about Tess.
This is written by the mind behind The Chronicles of St Mary’s, I think it’s supposed to be less weird than St Mary’s and it mostly is with the exception of an imaginary horse who smells of ginger biscuits! It actually put me in mind of Katie Fforde, it was a fun romp and had some very emotional moments. I haven’t bought the next book, but it’s only a matter of time
Another Brooklyn Bruisers ice hockey novel. It was fun while I was reading it but it felt like a novella because the h/h were underdeveloped. There was more here, the other ‘Bruisers’ books have been better developed.
This was my Christmas book (thanks Ma) and Sally Rooney is quite the sensation about now. This brilliantly captures the mix of certainty and uncertainty of being 21, and it’s lovely to read a Dublin novel that’s comfortable and unapologetically Irish in a way I haven’t seen before. Having said that I finished the novel without being any clearer about Frances and who she is. I might have to read it again but I was reminded of Barbara Pym and that’s not a compliment from me.